1. Atlas Home
2. Indiana
3. Town of Saint John
Rentometer Atlas BETA

St. John’s rental market stands out in Indiana for its strong emphasis on spacious single‑family homes, making it an attractive destination for families and professionals seeking a suburban lifestyle with easy access to Indianapolis. The city’s historic downtown, charming brick streets, and vibrant community events create a welcoming atmosphere, while nearby amenities such as the White River State Park and the renowned St. John Columbus Catholic School add to the appeal of this family‑focused locale.

Renters in St. John typically find a variety of well‑maintained houses ranging from three to four‑plus bedrooms. Three‑bedroom homes often command rates in the $3400 range, reflecting the city’s reputation for quality housing and convenient location. Larger four‑plus bedroom properties are generally available in the $3200 range, offering ample space for growing families or those who desire additional flexibility. The absence of apartment complexes in the current market underscores the city’s dedication to preserving a predominantly single‑family residential character.

Beyond housing, St. John boasts numerous parks, walking trails, and cultural attractions such as the historic St. John Town Hall and the annual St. John Art and Music Festival. Proximity to major highways and public transit options ensures a smooth commute to downtown Indianapolis, while local shopping centers, dining establishments, and recreational facilities provide everyday conveniences. These combined qualities make the St. John rental market a compelling choice for prospective tenants seeking a balanced blend of community charm and modern accessibility.

St. John Rent by Property Type & Bedroom Count

In the current period, the average rent in St. John was $3,369 for 3 Bedroom, and $3,164 for 4+ Bedroom.
Note: This analysis includes only bedroom types with sufficient data.

Data provided by Rentometer, Inc.