Average Rent in Huntington Bay, NY
Apartments & Houses by Size

Rentometer, Inc. | Data as of 10/23/2025

Huntington Bay, a charming city on Long Island’s North Shore, offers a distinctive blend of serene waterfront living and convenient access to metropolitan amenities. Known for its quiet, tree‑lined streets and picturesque bayside views, the community attracts families and professionals who value a peaceful environment while staying within commuting distance of New York City. The area’s well‑maintained parks, such as Little Hallock‑Nassau County Park, and its proximity to historic sites like the Bay Shore Village district add cultural depth and recreational options for residents.

The local rental market is dominated by spacious single‑family homes, many featuring four or more bedrooms that cater to larger households seeking ample living space. Renting a four‑plus bedroom house typically falls in the $7300‑$8000 range, reflecting the premium for expansive layouts, private yards, and often direct water access. These properties often include modern updates, open‑plan designs, and convenient garage or driveway parking, making them ideal for families and those who work from home.

Beyond the homes themselves, Huntington Bay boasts top‑rated schools, a strong sense of community, and a variety of dining and shopping options along nearby Huntington Avenue. Residents enjoy easy access to the Long Island Rail Road, providing a straightforward commute to Manhattan, as well as scenic boat launches for sailing enthusiasts. The combination of upscale rental options, natural beauty, and excellent connectivity makes Huntington Bay a sought‑after destination in the New York rental market.

Huntington Bay Rent by Property Type & Bedroom Count

Property Type Bedrooms Average Median Min - Max 25th - 75th
House 4+ Bedroom $7,350 $7,750 $5,900 - $8,000 $7,500 - $8,000

In the current period, the average rent in Huntington Bay was $7,133 for 4+ Bedroom.

Huntington Bay

Rentometer subscribers can see individual property locations on the map in addition to the heatmap. Click here to Subscribe

Data provided by Rentometer, Inc.