Rentometer, Inc. | Data as of 10/24/2025
Fire Island, a unique city nestled off the coast of Long Island, offers a distinctive blend of tranquil beach life and vibrant cultural scenes. Known for its pristine shoreline, protected dunes, and carâfree streets, the community attracts residents who value outdoor recreation, seaside festivals, and easy access to NewâŻYork City via ferry. Iconic landmarks such as the historic Fire Island Lighthouse and the beloved Sunken Forest provide natural beauty and recreational opportunities yearâround, making the area a prime destination for both fullâtime living and seasonal retreats.
The local rental market reflects Fire Islandâs exclusive coastal appeal, with a strong emphasis on spacious singleâfamily homes. Threeâbedroom houses typically command rents in the $9,700 range, with median rates around $8,500, while larger fourâplusâbedroom homes often trend toward the $9,500 range. A limited selection of apartments also contributes to the housing mix, catering to those seeking a more compact, lowâmaintenance option. These properties provide ample indoor and outdoor living spaces, perfect for families, remote workers, and anyone wanting to enjoy the islandâs relaxed lifestyle without sacrificing modern comforts.
Popular neighborhoods such as Cherry Grove, Fire Island Pines, and Ocean Bay Park each offer distinct characterâfrom vibrant nightlife and artistic gatherings to quiet, familyâfriendly enclaves. Proximity to waterfront promenades, boutique shops, and renowned dining spots enhances the rental experience, while convenient ferry routes keep the city wellâconnected to Manhattan and the greater NewâŻYork metropolitan area. Whether youâre hunting for a seasonal getaway or a yearâround residence, Fire Island rentals deliver a unique combination of seaside charm, community spirit, and upscale living.
| Property Type | Bedrooms | Average | Median | Min - Max | 25th - 75th |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| House | 3 Bedroom | $9,722 | $8,500 | $3,500 - $20,000 | $6,000 - $10,000 |
| House | 4+ Bedroom | $9,398 | $8,750 | $5,000 - $15,250 | $7,000 - $12,000 |
In the current period, the average rent in Fire Island was
$9,000 for 3 Bedroom, and
$9,312 for 4+ Bedroom.
Note: This analysis includes only bedroom types with sufficient data.
Data provided by Rentometer, Inc.