Rentometer, Inc. | Data as of 12/05/2025
Centre Island, a serene enclave nestled within the heart of New York City’s waterfront community, offers a distinctive rental landscape that blends historic charm with modern convenience. The market is dominated by spacious single‑family homes, reflecting the island’s low‑rise residential character and its appeal to families seeking a tranquil retreat from the city’s bustle. While apartments are virtually absent, the presence of well‑maintained houses provides renters with generous living spaces, private yards, and direct access to the island’s scenic shoreline.
For those seeking larger accommodations, three‑bedroom houses represent the flagship offering on Centre Island. These homes typically command an average rent in the $12,000 range, with median rates reaching the mid‑$14,000s, underscoring the premium placed on space, privacy, and waterfront views. The rental inventory often includes classic brownstones and modern colonial‑style residences, each featuring ample bedrooms, updated kitchens, and proximity to the island’s lush parks and marinas.
Beyond its housing options, Centre Island boasts a vibrant community atmosphere highlighted by attractions such as the historic Centre Island Club, a series of manicured walking trails, and private beaches that draw both residents and visitors alike. Easy ferry service to nearby Manhattan and excellent local schools further enhance the island’s desirability as a long‑term rental destination. Whether you’re drawn by the appeal of spacious homes, the allure of waterfront living, or the close‑knit community vibe, Centre Island presents a compelling rental market for discerning renters in New York.
| Property Type | Bedrooms | Average | Median | Min - Max | 25th - 75th |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| House | 3 Bedroom | $12,166 | $14,750 | $7,000 - $14,750 | $7,000 - $14,750 |
In the current period, the average rent in Centre Island was
$12,167 for 3 Bedroom.
Note: This analysis includes only bedroom types with sufficient data.
Data provided by Rentometer, Inc.