Average Rent in Centre Island, NY
Apartments & Houses by Size

Rentometer, Inc. | Data as of 10/23/2025

Centre Island, a charming city enclave in New York, offers a distinctive rental market that appeals to families and professionals seeking spacious living environments. The area is known for its lush waterfront views, historic architecture, and convenient access to local amenities such as the Center Island Yacht Club, Glen Cove Park, and a variety of boutique dining options. Its tranquil streets and proximity to both downtown Manhattan and the scenic Long Island Sound make it an attractive choice for those who value a balanced, upscale lifestyle.

Rental options on Centre Island are primarily comprised of single‑family homes, with a strong emphasis on larger floor plans that cater to growing households. Three‑bedroom houses typically fall within the $12,000 to $15,000 range, while larger four‑plus‑bedroom properties trend toward the $13,000 to $16,000 bracket. These homes often feature modern renovations, private yards, and generous living spaces, reflecting the area's reputation for quality family housing. Prospective renters appreciate the blend of historic charm and contemporary comforts that define the neighbourhoods surrounding the island’s historic waterfront and the scenic walking trails of the nearby Nassau County parks.

Beyond the appealing housing stock, Centre Island benefits from excellent transportation links, top‑rated schools, and a vibrant community atmosphere. Residents enjoy easy access to cultural attractions, recreational facilities, and a range of local services that enhance everyday living. Whether you’re looking for a spacious family home or a serene retreat within the bustling New York metropolitan area, Centre Island’s rental market provides a compelling combination of convenience, elegance, and community charm.

Partial Data Available: We have sufficient data for 3 Bedroom listings. Other bedroom types need more data for reliable statistics.

Centre Island Rent by Property Type & Bedroom Count

Property Type Bedrooms Average Median Min - Max 25th - 75th
House 3 Bedroom $12,166 $14,750 $7,000 - $14,750 $7,000 - $14,750

In the current period, the average rent in Centre Island was $12,167 for 3 Bedroom.
Note: This analysis includes only bedroom types with sufficient data.

Centre Island

Rentometer subscribers can see individual property locations on the map in addition to the heatmap. Click here to Subscribe

Data provided by Rentometer, Inc.