Rentometer, Inc. | Data as of 12/04/2025
Old Tappan’s rental market blends suburban charm with convenient access to New York City, making it a sought‑after spot for professionals and families alike. The community features a mix of single‑family homes and multifamily buildings, offering a range of living spaces from cozy one‑bedroom apartments to spacious three‑bedroom units. Residents enjoy well‑maintained streets, tree‑lined neighborhoods, and a strong sense of community, while being just minutes from major commuter routes and public transportation hubs.
Apartment rentals in Old Tappan are particularly popular, with two‑bedroom units typically falling in the $4200 range and three‑bedroom options averaging around $5300. These modern apartments often include amenities such as in‑unit laundry, updated kitchens, and secure parking, catering to both young professionals and growing families. The area’s proximity to acclaimed schools, parks, and recreational facilities adds to its appeal, especially for those looking for a balanced lifestyle that combines convenience with a relaxed suburban atmosphere.
Beyond housing, Old Tappan boasts a vibrant local scene anchored by the historic downtown district, charming eateries, and boutique shops. Outdoor enthusiasts can explore nearby nature trails, golf courses, and the scenic Pascack Valley. Whether you’re seeking a quiet neighborhood with excellent schools or a well‑connected location for commuting, Old Tappan’s rental options provide flexibility and quality living within the thriving New Jersey rental market.
| Property Type | Bedrooms | Average | Median | Min - Max | 25th - 75th |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Apartment | 2 Bedroom | $4,229 | $4,200 | $4,150 - $4,338 | $4,150 - $4,338 |
| Apartment | 3 Bedroom | $5,278 | $5,492 | $4,250 - $6,092 | $4,250 - $6,092 |
In the current period, the average rent in Old Tappan was
$4,229 for 2 Bedroom, and
$5,278 for 3 Bedroom.
Note: This analysis includes only bedroom types with sufficient data.
Data provided by Rentometer, Inc.